Deceptions in Reporting Alcohol as Healthy
CategoriesWhen the media reports a study showing alcohol consumption as healthy, I would encourage the reading of the original study and the editorial comments to get an accurate assessment. In the New England Journal of Medicine (January 9, 2003), there was a study that attributed the frequency of alcohol use to a reduced risk of a heart attack. The lead researcher, Dr. Kenneth Mukamal of Harvard University suggested that maintaining a low level of exposure is the way to go, yet closer scrutiny shows that important information was omitted.
In the editorial comments in this same issue, by Ira J. Goldberg, MD, there were some revealing facts about this study that were not mentioned in the media. Those in the non-alcoholic group had less physical activity, lower vitamin E intake, more diabetes, and a higher intake of trans-and saturated fat. Also Dr. Goldberg wondered if the alcohol-consuming groups might have other lifestyle factors associated with reduced risk. He said, not everything fits, as alcohol does not reliably reduce arteriosclerosis in animals, and without data from clinical trials, it is unclear how a physician can be in a position to advise his or her patients. The toxic effect of alcohol is well established, whereas the data on alcohol and cardiovascular disease is not.
In those who drink alcoholic beverages, some studies show a reduction in cardiovascular disease but not in overall mortality. A number of preventive therapies, such as exercise, cessation of smoking, lowering cholesterol levels and blood pressure do not have the undesirable effects of alcohol, concluded Dr. Goldberg, substitution of one disease for another is not a medical advance.
Check here lowering cholesterol levels and blood pressure for some more deceptions... CG
Another news item suggesting that alcohol has a positive effect on diabetics was challenged by Wake Forest University School of Medicine because one of the important risk factors was omitted weight/body mass index. When this was included in the Wake Forest study, there was no benefit. Another media report said that wine was associated with better lung function. However, the researchers in this study attributed the improvement to the antioxidants in the wine - not the alcohol, and they warned of resulting oxidative stress. Other less publicized, but equally valid, studies show that wine consumption makes the lung liable to injury and increases the risk of allergic reactions.
These following facts are also missing from media reports: in 2000, our government declared alcoholic beverages to be a class A human carcinogen, along with arsenic and asbestos. According to a study in the British Medical Journal, drinking as little as one alcoholic beverage a day can raise the risk of mouth, throat, and esophageal cancer: seven to ten drinks a week increases the risk three times. Individuals who regularly consume alcohol show no improvement in general health, since they die more often from strokes, cancer, accidents, and violence. The medias pro-alcohol reporting and regular omission of the dangers and risks should be of concern to the public. Just as with alcohol, there are health benefits from tobacco (nicotine), but the dangers from each of these drugs far outweigh any benefits.
posted by Chris Gupta on Sunday November 2 2003
updated on Saturday September 24 2005URL of this article:
http://www.newmediaexplorer.org/chris/2003/11/02/deceptions_in_reporting_alcohol_as_healthy.htm
Related ArticlesMagnesium: Research Misconduct?
Here is another example of how systematically - the pharmaceuticals manipulate safe and cost effective solutions and put us at risk and all the time extolling their self serving concern for the patient. Just one, of far too many, examples of this sort of thing happening time after time. Its sad to see how the researchers get sucked into these! This is an update that includes links and error corrections.... [read more]
October 23, 2005 - Chris GuptaBRUSSELS SPROUTS MORE CONTROLS
Please go to STOP BRUSSELS FROM KILLING NATURAL MEDICINE and take action now. Thanks Chris Gupta ..."the importance of B6, and the other vitamin B compounds. In the same week that the FSA produced its weighty document, the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA) published a study of heart patients who had had an angioplasty. Usually, around 20 per cent of all angioplasty patients need a repeat operation within... [read more]
August 31, 2003 - Chris GuptaTen drugs to avoid whenever possible
It just keeps getting better and better for the medical Mafia. Continue pumping us with more toxins and just deal with symptoms. Thus creating a whole horde of future customers (patients) - Gee I wonder why they are so set against safe nutritional alternatives?? What a bonanza! Chris Gupta 1. Prozac. This wonder drug whose side effects are now being uncovered. Aside from all the known side effects, including insomnia,... [read more]
July 27, 2003 - Chris Gupta
