Food Supplements: Italy Allows More Nutrient Sources
Italian Health Minister Sirchia has given both producers and consumers of supplements a welcome break by allowing a long list of vitamin and mineral sources to remain on the market which otherwise would have become illegal in July, in accordance with new European rules for supplements.
The European food supplements directive, which has been challenged before the EU Court of Justice, lists permitted vitamins and minerals, as well as sources or chemical forms of these vitamins and minerals which may be used in the formulation of food supplements. The lists are exclusive, meaning that any substance not on the list will either have to be "proven safe" by extensive (and expensive) scientific documentation or products containing it will have to be taken off the market. According to the Alliance for Natural Health, which has initiated the legal challenge against the prohibition clause of the directive, the lists are very restrictive, typically only listing the isolated chemical substances and inorganic mineral salts which have been used by pharmaceutical manufacturers for decades, making the more natural "food-like" substances illegal to sell or buy.
According to the EU supplements directive, individual countries in the EU have the possibility to grant extension for nutrients and their sources currently used on the market, until the year 2009. In accordance with the provisions of the directive, the Italian Ministry of Health has published a list of additional nutrients and nutrient sources that will be acceptable on the Italian market until proven safe or until the extension runs out in December of 2009.
The list contains five additional minerals - vanadium, boron, nickel, tin and silica - as well as a great number of vitamin and mineral sources that were on the Italian market on 31 July 2003, when the Food Supplements directive was first published. The Italian industry association Federsalus worked closely with ministry officials in drafting the list.
An unofficial translation of the Italian ministerial decree follows here:
MINISTRY OF HEALTH
Decree of 17 February 2005
List of minerals and of vitamin-mineral sources permitted in food supplements in addition to those listed in annexes I and II of the legislative decree of 21 May 2004, number 169, in application of article 3, 3rd paragraph, of that same legislative decree.
THE MINISTER OF HEALTH
Having examined community directive 46/2002/EC of the European Parliament and the Council, of 10 June 2002 on the approximation of the laws of the Member States relating to food supplements;
Having examined the legislative decree of 21 May 2004, number 169, which has implemented the aforesaid directive and in particular its article 3, 3rd paragraph;
Considering that in the past, food supplements were put on the market under the procedure of article 7 of legislative decree of 27 January 1992, number 111, on products destined for particular nutritional uses;
Having taken stock of the minerals and the vitamin-mineral sources used in food supplements put on the market at or before 31 July 2003 following the notification procedure of article 7 of the legislative decree number 111/1992;
Considering it necessary to publish the list of substances as per article 3, 2nd paragraph of legislative decree number 169/2004;
Having obtained the opinion of the competent consultative commission as per article 11 of legislative decree number 169/2004 on 17 December 1004;
Decrees:Article 1.
1. Until 31 December 2009, the annex I of legislative decree 169/2004 is extended to include the minerals listed in annex I of the present decree.
2. In case of a negative opinion of the European Agency for Food Safety about the use of minerals included in annex I to this decree, the Ministry of Health will update the annex without delay to eliminate any minerals that have received a negative evaluation.Article 2.
1. Until 31 December 2009, the annex II of legislative decree 169/2004 is extended to include the vitamin-mineral sources listed in annex II of the present decree.
2. In the case of a negative opinion of the European Agency for Food Safety about the use of vitamin-mineral sources included in annex II to this decree, the Minister of Health will update the annex without delay to eliminate any vitamin-mineral sources that have been negatively evaluated.Rome, 17 February 2005 The Minister: Sirchia
Annex I
List of minerals permitted in food supplements in addition to those listed in annex I of legislative decree number 169/2004Vanadium
Boron
Nickel
Tin
SilicaAnnex II
List of vitamin-mineral sources permitted in food supplements in addition to those listed in annex II of legislative decree number 169/2004Vitamin B 1:
thiamin monophosphate
Vitamin C and niacin:
nicotinamide ascorbate
Vitamin B 6:
pyridoxine dipalitate
Vitamin E:
succinate of d-alpha-tocopherol poliethylene glycole 1000Boron:
boric acid
sodium borateCalcium:
aminoacid chelate
calcium pidolate
calcium sulphate
calcium phosphate
calcium fluoride
calcium acetate
calcium piruvate
calcium chelate
calcium aspartate
calcium lysinate
calcium methionate
calcium orotate
[calcium] on yeast
calcium folinate
[calcium] from dolomite (carbonate of Ca and Mg)Fluoride:
sodium monofluoride phosphate
Chromium:
aminoacid chelate
chromium picolinate
chromium polycholinate
[chromium] on yeast
chromium orotate
chromium nitrate
chromium pidolate
chromium ascorbateCopper:
aminoacid chelate
copper oxide
copper orotate
[copper] on yeast
copper glycinate
copper pidolate
copper aspartate
copper glycirinateNickel:
nickel sulphateIron:
ferrous hydroxide
ferrous pidolate
aminoacid chelate
iron glycerophosphate
iron orthophosphate
[iron] on yeast
iron orotate
iron aspartate
iron picolinate
iron ascorbate
[iron] oxidesSelenium:
[selenium] on yeast
selenium aspartate
selenomethionine
aminoacid chelate
selenium proteinate
selenium ascorbateSodium:
sodium ascorbate
sodium silicate
sodium metasilicate
sodium vanadiate
sodium metavanadiate
sodium molybdate
sodium molybdate dihydrate
sodium sulphate
sodium borate
sodium tetraborate decahydrate
sodium tetraborate anhydro
sodium pyruvate
sodium pidolate
sodium aspartateMagnesium:
aminoacid chelate
magnesium pidolate
magnesium piruvate
magnesium DL-aspartate
magnesium L-aspartate
magnesium orotate
magnesium pidolate
magnesium lysinate
magnesium methionate
[magnesium] on yeast
[magnesium] from dolomite (carbonate of Ca and Mg)
magnesium succinate
magnesium hypophosphate
magnesium aspartateManganese:
aminoacid chelate
manganese aspartate
[manganese] on yeast
manganese pidolate
manganese orotate
manganese ascorbateZinc:
aminoacid chelate
zinc methionine
zinc orotate
zinc pidolate
zinc stearate
[zinc] on yeast
zinc aspartate
zinc phosphate
zinc picolinate
zinc ascorbatePotassium:
potassium aspartate
potassium phosphate (dibase and monobase)
potassium DL-aspartate
potassium glutamate
potassium L-aspartate
potassium sulphate
[potassium] on yeast
potassium pidolate
potassium molybdate
potassium orotate
aminoacid chelate
potassium piruvate
potassium caseinate
[potassium] monopersulphateSilica:
silica dioxideTin:
tin chlorideVanadium:
vanadyl chelate
vanadyl sulphateMolybdenum:
[molybdenum] on yeast
aminoacid chelate
molybdenum aspartate
molybdenum ascorbateIodine
on yeastPhosphorus:
aminoacid chelate
phosphorus proteinate
[phosphorus] on yeast08.03.2005 - Government Printing Office and Mint - 09:45:21
See also:A list of the nutrients and sources missing from the Food Supplements Directive's positive lists has just gone up on the site of CHC - Consumers for Health Choice, in the UK. Ingredients that have already obtained derogation (in the UK) are marked with ** whilst those that CHC believe are likely to obtain derogation in the near future are marked ++.
posted by Sepp Hasslberger on Monday March 14 2005
updated on Tuesday December 21 2010URL of this article:
http://www.newmediaexplorer.org/sepp/2005/03/14/food_supplements_italy_allows_more_nutrient_sources.htm
Related ArticlesFood Supplements in Europe - What is the Problem?
The European Union has issued a Directive to regulate the commerce of food supplements, which is in the process of being implemented in the member states. If reading the referenced text does not tell you what problems this directive might bring to your ability to either buy or sell supplements in one of the European Community member states, don't feel alone. That is a problem most observers have and I... [read more]
April 21, 2004 - Sepp HasslbergerEU Supplements Directive 'Is Good For Consumers' - British MP
Geoff Sherman of Pembrokeshire asked his Member of Parliament, NICK AINGER MP/AS, the House of Commons' Labour Member for Carmarthen West and South Pembrokeshire, why food supplements are being banned by the British government on behest of the European Community, when there are really no problems with these products as they are, and when many people like himself find nutrients a good way to keep in perfect health. The response... [read more]
February 03, 2005 - Sepp HasslbergerSupplements: EU Court Hears Case As UK Commons Debate Directive
Luxembourg - The European Court of Justice heard oral arguments yesterday in a case brought by the Alliance for Natural Health, the British Health Food Manufacturers Association and the National Association of Health Food Stores, to overturn the prohibitive provisions of the European food supplements directive. The directive, passed in 2002 for the purpose of harmonizing European laws on health products, is set to require expensive research to prove the... [read more]
January 26, 2005 - Sepp HasslbergerFood Supplements: German Risk Institute Takes Dim View
The German Federal Institute for Risk Evaluation, formerly the Federal Office for Consumer Health Protection, has established a risk assessment model for deducing maximum safe levels of nutrients provided in supplements and fortified foods, according to a recent report of nutraingredients.com. The report was published in two parts, one dealing with minerals, the other with vitamins, both available in PDF format - so far only in German language (Minerals here)... [read more]
January 20, 2005 - Sepp HasslbergerConventional Medicine Far Riskier Than Supplements
This is a good summary of all the machinations regarding the bogus regulations for vitamins etc. Just follow the money... Chris Gupta Conventional Medicine - Far Riskier Than Supplements by Barbara Sumner Burstyn The panic over the blanket recall of alternative treatments manufactured by Pan Pharmaceuticals was way out of proportion to the facts. Hands up if you threw out all your vitamins last month just to be on the... [read more]
October 15, 2003 - Chris GuptaFoods Are Medicines: The Elusive Borderline
" Let thy food be thy medicine and thy medicine be thy food." Hippocrates (460-377 BC) We might say that the debate of what is food and what is medicine goes back more than two thousand years, to Hippocrates, the Greek physician who is also known as the father of modern scientific medicine. In the early 1960s, pharmaceutical medicines were in the headlines with a tragic development. Mothers who had... [read more]
September 28, 2004 - Sepp Hasslberger
