Denmark To Eliminate Concept Of Supplements: 'They're All Medicines'
August 2004 - Danish Health Authorities have issued a proposed national "Guidance on Supplements" for public discussion which, according to MayDay, an association campaigning for freedom of choice in health matters, "is worse than any legislation we have ever seen before, as it will erase the concept of supplements, this actually means that Denmark is about to be the most totalitarian state experiment in Europe concerning health."
The Danes refer to the new definition of a "medicinal product" recently passed in the EU legislature, which declares any substance presented for preventing disease as well as substances which may be administered to human beings with a view to restoring, correcting or modifying physiological functions to be a medicinal product.
A substance could be anything from human blood to animals and their products, vegetables, micro-organisms, plants, parts of plants and even chemicals, whether natural or synthetic.
Source: The Community code relating to medicinal products for human use.
Pretty comprehensive, you say? Well, it seems like we Europeans have just declared our food supply, practically anything we'd ever want to swallow to stay healthy, to be medicinal and therefore subject to pharmaceutical control.
It's as simple as that. Anything we eat - if we eat well as the health authorities admonish us to - will serve to prevent one illness or the other, won't it? Why else would we be admonished to eat five servings of fruit and vegetables per day? But beyond that, any food and drink we consume will restore some type of physiological function in our bodies. Practically, everything we ever want to swallow to stay healthy, is potentially a pharmaceutical medicine if we are to give credence to that legal definition.
But that's crazy, you might say, no one ever will seriously seriously assert that an apple is a medicine just because one a day keeps the doctor away. Agreed, but there are many products such as supplements and herbs that pharmaceutical manufacturers eye with great envy. They help people stay healthy without side effects. They actually prevent, like simple vitamin C in gram dosages, major killer diseases. More than we can say for the majority of drugs, which, on the contrary, have become a factor in increasing death rates as shown by statistical evidence.
Nutrients and plants, extracts and concentrates from natural food sources, unlike the apple, will certainly be called a medicine and put under pharma monopolistic control, if shown to be "effective", that is, if they take business away from the sickness industry that the pharmaceutical manufacturers have built.
The phenomenon is by no means isolated to tiny Denmark. Other European countries such as Germany and Finland are reasoning along similar lines - protect pharmaceutical production - it is an important "industry". But what about our health? That industry thrives only when we are sick. Should we go so far as to lose our health in order to support an industry?
You might say no, but what can you do about it?
Alert your friends to this and other sites that write about health freedom. Make your view known to your favorite newspaper, magazine or your legislative representative. If you like to be healthy and are using nutrition and other natural means to stay so, it's time to defend your rights. One of these rights is certainly the ability to use food and nutrition to stay healthy, without pharmaceutical interference.
If you are an "operator", someone in industry or in natural health consulting, please support the Alliance for Natural Health, the only group that is taking effective steps to prevent a pharmaceutical takeover of the natural health field.
If you are a legislator or a "regulator", think about the concept of non-exclusivity of the definition of a medicine. Let me explain: We define medicine in a very wide way, so as to catch all products that should have registration. There is however considerable overlap into other - equally important - areas of products, such as foods and supplements, many of which do have the same properties as medicines. They prevent disease and they restore or correct physiological functions. (Hippocrates already said "let food be thy medicine...").
When there is a conflict between the legal concept of food and that of a medicine requiring registration, the latter is destined to win out if we consider current EU legislation. This is not correct. Food should definitely have MORE importance than medicine, unless we want to drown in a sea of sickness. Addressing only sickness and "treating" only the symptoms, pharmaceutical medicine is taking us in that direction...
See here below MayDay's alert from Denmark, and some relevant links:
HEALTH FREEDOM UNDER SERIOUS THREAT IN THE TOTALITARIAN STATE OF DENMARK
Another paternalistic assault on free choice and liberty using "consumer safety" as an excuse.
The Danish Veterinary and food Administration has sent out a Guidance on dietary supplements (and herbs) as a public hearing notice, in short stating that any substance with a physiological effect is to be regarded as a medicine in the future.
This means that the concept of "dietary supplements" will soon no longer exist and that a lot of widely used and harmless dietary supplements and herbs will be disappearing from Danish health shops shelves by November 2004. Gone is the freedom of choice for the many seeking to maintain and restore good health and life quality and prevent sickness.
Such nannyism is totally unacceptable!
MayDay has long been concerned that such legislative restrictions can be expected throughout EUrope in the time to come.
MayDay invites all health freedom loving people to support our work to inform about unjust measures from government authorities and ensure free personal choice in health matters.
Please go to MayDay's website: www.mayday-info.dk where it is possible to sign up to be a member and/or support the Alliance for Natural Health's legal challenge of the EU Food Supplements Directive.
Danes are requested to protest against these serious restrictions writing to their favorite newspaper and/or politician and/or the Danish Ministry of Food, Agriculture and Fisheries (firstname.lastname@example.org) plus the Danish Veterinary and food Administration (email@example.com).
Tamara Theresa Mosegaard
MayDay, Civil Health Rights Movement
Rundforbivej 2, Troeroed
DK - 2960 Vedbaek
Tel.: +45 4499 8898
Fax: +45 4565 0599
For more information on Health Freedom:
"SAFETY" IS THE EXCUSE TO KILL FREEDOM IN EUROPE: A REPORT FROM DENMARK
by Tamara ThťrŤsa Mosegaard
Danish legislation covering food supplements is notorious for being harsh and restrictive. Yet, as harsh and restrictive as Danish food-supplement legislation has been, at least it was limited to Denmark. That is now changing in a dramatic way as Europe adopts a virtually continent-wide set of rules and regulations governing food supplements that is extremely harsh and anti-health freedom.
posted by Sepp Hasslberger on Tuesday September 7 2004
updated on Tuesday December 21 2010
URL of this article:
Conventional medicine far riskier than supplements
Barbara Sumner Burstyn, in an article in the New Zealand Herald comments on the recent Australian attack on natural products which of course was felt also by New Zealand's health food aficionados. "...a blanket recall caused people to doubt not only the effectiveness of vitamins and supplements but their safety. We may have been looking in the wrong direction. While the Pan medication put 19 Australians in hospital, and others... [read more]
June 16, 2003 - Sepp Hasslberger
Supplements: EU Court Hears Case As UK Commons Debate Directive
Luxembourg - The European Court of Justice heard oral arguments yesterday in a case brought by the Alliance for Natural Health, the British Health Food Manufacturers Association and the National Association of Health Food Stores, to overturn the prohibitive provisions of the European food supplements directive. The directive, passed in 2002 for the purpose of harmonizing European laws on health products, is set to require expensive research to prove the... [read more]
January 26, 2005 - Sepp Hasslberger
European Supplements Directive challenged in London Court
The European Union's Directive on Food Supplements, which became EU law last year and is now being transposed into the legal systems of EU member states, has been challenged in a UK court on Monday 13 October by the Alliance for Natural Health (ANH) a pan-European coalition of supplement manufacturers, retailers, independent health practitioners and consumers. The case, filed in the London High Court by Brick Court Chambers and the... [read more]
October 16, 2003 - Sepp Hasslberger
Understanding The Pharmacartel Assault On Supplements
I know, I know, this is beginning to sound like a broken record, But most of the value of the information we have today and in the future will become useless if we are not able to procure the nutrients that we need to manage our own health. I implore you to at least understand the issues and act appropriately based on your own conclusions. At the moment the only... [read more]
October 22, 2004 - Chris Gupta
Food Supplements in Europe - What is the Problem?
The European Union has issued a Directive to regulate the commerce of food supplements, which is in the process of being implemented in the member states. If reading the referenced text does not tell you what problems this directive might bring to your ability to either buy or sell supplements in one of the European Community member states, don't feel alone. That is a problem most observers have and I... [read more]
April 21, 2004 - Sepp Hasslberger
Food Supplements: German Risk Institute Takes Dim View
The German Federal Institute for Risk Evaluation, formerly the Federal Office for Consumer Health Protection, has established a risk assessment model for deducing maximum safe levels of nutrients provided in supplements and fortified foods, according to a recent report of nutraingredients.com. The report was published in two parts, one dealing with minerals, the other with vitamins, both available in PDF format - so far only in German language (Minerals here)... [read more]
January 20, 2005 - Sepp Hasslberger